Love&Learn
Ask a Question
beccane
yellbut.gif
yellbut.gif
dblubut.gif

Back to Patra's Answer

 
Why can’t I look at beautiful women?

Patra said:

I disagree because this kind of puritanical thinking is what made the last 2000 years full of misplaced aggression, emotional and physical abuse of women, widespread divorce, lying and philandering.

Reader Beccane Responds:

Respect Each Other's Values

I disagree because it cuts both ways; if you want religious people to respect your values you have to respect religious values as well.

I grew up strictly atheist with parents who told me religion is the root of various evils. I think that was narrow-minded – we all are travelling through life trying to find structures and meaning that reflect our values. Our values are often very similar – we want to be loved, to be safe, to be happy, healthy, wise etc etc. It's how we think we can get there that differs.

Is sexual fantasy the cause of temptation (and presumably unhappiness) or a harmless cure? Intelligent well-meaning people can disagree.

Dogmatic Ideas

I agree that terms like "sin" can be loaded and tend to put cold water on discussion by making things seem black and white. But religion is not THE cause of all the terrible things you cite ("misplaced aggression, emotional and physical abuse of women, widespread divorce, lying and philandering"). In fact, phrasing things that way is just as dogmatic as any religious sermon. So let's tone down the hyperbole and disagree without attacking the deeply held beliefs of others.

Beccane

 

Click here to see the full question & other panelists' responses.

What do you think of this Answer?

What part are you reacting to?

What do you think?

Signature to use with your reaction:

Your gender:

Male:
Female:

Your age:

Your location:

optional: email address (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)

 

 

 

 

Site Design by:
Bleeding Edge Design